Who should be our main Midfielders?

[Sloid]

When everyone is fit, who do you prefer to be our main midfield pairing?

Last season, our main MF duet was Carrick & Scholes & we end up as Champions. So what do you think? Don't change the winning team? or should we try different pairing?

For me personally, I want to see a Hargreaves - Scholes pairing, with Carrick & Anderson as back up, but after seeing Anderson's display against Wigan, I don't mind seeing a Hargreaves - Anderson experiment someday...

Thoughts....?

[Ken-Ob]

With new signings are coming...

How about we pair Hargreaves - Carrick as CM and Anderson/Scholes for AM... Then they will be supporting the new tridente (Rooney - Tevez - Ronaldo with Nani and Giggs as backups)

[Dann496]

Anderson pass to Ronaldo yesterday was out of this world.

[Sloid]

Scholes, Hargreaves, Carrick, Anderson, Park, Fletcher, O'Shea, Gibson, even Nani, Giggs & Pique can play there...

I would hate to be Fergie when everyone is fit, he'd have a hard time picking out who's playing & who's not... LOL

[benhanks040888]

I actually wanna see 4-2-1-3 or 4-2-3-1 formation where Carrick and Hargreaves play as DMs and Scholes in front of them as AM, backed up but not replaced by Anderson. However, really impossible if SAF is still on the ship...

Don't judge Anderson just for one beautiful pass or one great performance. How many beautiful passes have Scholes, Carrick, etc done? Lots, but not appreciated as much as it should cos they're not Anderson or "talented players"?

[Sloid]

Originally Posted by benhanks040888

I actually wanna see 4-2-1-3 or 4-2-3-1 formation where Carrick and Hargreaves play as DMs and Scholes in front of them as AM, backed up but not replaced by Anderson. However, really impossible if SAF is still on the ship...

Don't judge Anderson just for one beautiful pass or one great performance. How many beautiful passes have Scholes, Carrick, etc done? Lots, but not appreciated as much as it should cos they're not Anderson or "talented players"?

Personal vendetta aside, I share your feeling bro, I too, want to see a 4-2-3-1, but only when we're playing in Europe or against tougher oppositions, as there's no point playing 2 DMs IF the opponents never attack us, that's the case with a lot of smaller teams in the Premiership.

--HARGREAVES----CARRICK---
RONALDO---SCHOLES---TEVEZ
------------ROONEY----------

but IF Scholes keep playing the way he played this season, I want to see this:

--HARGREAVES----CARRICK---
RONALDO---ROONEY----TEVEZ
-------------SAHA-----------

Then, next season, we will see more of Anderson & Nani, where they'll gradually replace Scholes & Giggs respectively... (fingers crossed)

[Dann496]

Originally Posted by benhanks040888

Don't judge Anderson just for one beautiful pass or one great performance. How many beautiful passes have Scholes, Carrick, etc done? Lots, but not appreciated as much as it should cos they're not Anderson or "talented players"?

Please refresh me, for I could not recall any passes by Scholes and Carrick that as good as Anderson's for Ronaldo in the Wigan match. It is so much full of vision and beautifully calculated, shame is Ronaldo failed to catch up with the ball. If he did, I am sure those match will end more than 4-0

[kurel]

Originally Posted by Dann496

Please refresh me, for I could not recall any passes by Scholes and Carrick that as good as Anderson's for Ronaldo in the Wigan match. It is so much full of vision and beautifully calculated, shame is Ronaldo failed to catch up with the ball. If he did, I am sure those match will end more than 4-0

i guess bro benhanks just trying to point out that it's only anderson's 1st good game with United while scholesy and carrick have done it consistently week in week out.
scholes pass to rooney against ac milan was as good as anderson's.
carrick have plenty of wonderful passes in our last game against chelsea.

[Dann496]

Originally Posted by kurel

i guess bro benhanks just trying to point out that it's only anderson's 1st good game with United while scholesy and carrick have done it consistently week in week out.
scholes pass to rooney against ac milan was as good as anderson's.
carrick have plenty of wonderful passes in our last game against chelsea.

Noted though I still think Anderson pass in so much better vision.

But u got to forgive me since I am a very biased fans of AnderShow.

[scholsy]

--Ronaldo-----Hargreaves-----Scholes-----Giggs--
---------------------Tevez----------------------
---------------------Rooney---------------------

Reasons:
1. Both Hargreaves and Scholes have huge experience in UCL
2. Giggs will not be able omit from the squad, without him MU is unbalanced

The reserve team should be
--JS PARK-----Carrick-----Anderson------Nani--
---------------------????---------------------
---------------------Saha--------------------

????....I always said we lack of 1 senior experience striker/forward
1999 treble we were equipped with 4 senior striker Cole,Yorke,Teddy,Ole
2007, I hope we were equipped with 4 senior striker as well but currently we only have Rooney, Tevez and Saha